Chapter VIII – The Character of Christ: His Death
For let this disposition be in you, which is in Christ Jesus also,
Who, being inherently in the form of God, deems it not pillaging to be equal
with God, nevertheless empties Himself, taking the form of a slave, coming to
be in the likeness of humanity, and, being found in fashion as a human, He
humbles Himself, becoming
obedient unto death, even the death of the cross.
genomenos (BECOMing) hupEkoos (OBEDIENT) mechri (UNTO)
thanatou (DEATH) de (YET) tou (OF-THE) staurou (PALE)
Two Deaths
“It has been said, and
truly said, ‘The supreme crises of history are centered in the disobedience
of the first man (Adam) and in the obedience of the Second (Christ).’ Adam
disobeyed the only command God had given to him and, in so doing,
revolted against the authority of God. The second Man ‘humbles Himself,
becoming obedient unto death, even the death of the cross’ (Phil.2:8).”
– Dean Hough, Unsearchable Riches, Volume 98, p. 174
There are two aspects to the humbling of Christ:
1. His obedience unto death
2. His obedience unto the death of the cross
Both are deserving of their own consideration, and we will do so.
Considerable length will be given to the latter, but it is important to stress
the former before anything else, for the Trinitarian disbelieves it, and the
Socinian often ignores it, through their own claims on the passage.
Obedience Unto Death
Death is humiliating. It is absent from the concept of “nature,” which
we briefly touched upon in the last chapter, and which I (Stephen) touch
on when considering Rom. 2:14 in my Romans study. It is directly affiliated
with sin (Rom. 5:12.) Where there is sin, there is death. Where there is death,
there is sin. The proof that we are imperfect is found in the degradation of
our bodily functions over the course of our lives.
Unfortunately, because we psychologically come to take horrific things
as a matter of course, death is not treated as the enemy that it is. Mankind,
especially in the 21st century, has taken up an unhealthy nihilism,
in all ways turning its nose up at scripture while hardly observing scripture’s
reason for the great purpose of death.
Scripture resolves the “death” conundrum through Jesus Christ. It takes
the Image of God, changes His form, and establishes Him as a human embryo on
the earth. He goes from the form of God – from observing creation at its
beginning, properly representing the Father, saying, “It is good” – to a crying
baby. He was the most helpless Subjector in the universe. He needed help with
the umbilical cord. He was plopped in a cow trough, in the middle of nowhere.
He cried, with only His mother’s warmth to console Him.
There are many exhortations on the life of Jesus, His growth in wisdom
and stature (Luke 2:53,) His baptism, in which it is affirmed for Him that He
is the Son of God (Matt. 3:16,) and His various signs to and for the Jewish
community. Through all of these, Jesus’ body grew. It changed. He got hot. He
got cold. He was hungry – sometimes went hungry. His body appeared older
than it was (John 8:57.)
The previous paragraph baffled the apostles. They knew there was
something off about Him (Matt. 8:28.) They recognized His position as a Son of
God (Matt. 16:15-16.) They struggled with His bold claims, as everyone else did
(John 6:61-62.) If this One truly represented what the title – Son of God –
truly implied, then why did He look like them? Why did He appear
in such a frail form, such a contemptible condition?
Such juxtaposition, in our opinion, finds its zenith in the four
accounts in John 13–
Jesus, being aware that the Father has given all into His hands, and
that He came out from God and is going away to God, is rising from dinner and
is laying down His garments, and, getting a cloth, He girds Himself. Thereafter
He is draining water into the basin, and begins washing the feet of the
disciples and wiping them off with the cloth with which He was girded.
He is coming, then, to Simon Peter. And he is saying to Him, “Lord,
You are washing my feet!”
Jesus answered and said to him, “What I am doing you are not aware at
present, yet you will know after these things.”
This One – that has received all from the Creator of the universe
– gets down on His knees and washes the feet of some hick fisherman. This was so
radical, that even the fisherman was uncomfortable. But it drives
the point home perfectly. Jesus’ disposition is not one of haughty impatience,
but humility in light of the allotment He held.
The shame of His body’s decay, then, cannot be understated. And here, in
Philippians, Paul deepens our understanding far above John’s epistle. In
all three prison epistles, he continually pushes us to consider things from the
celestial perspective (Eph. 1:3, 10, 20, 2:6, 3:10, 6:12, Phil. 2:10,
3:20, Col. 1:5, 16, 20, etc.) which is why He began the greatest example of
self-abasement with Christ’s emptying. Here, Jesus was not merely “coerced”
into a frightening situation, as one could reason out from the four accounts.
Even before His ministry, before He may have even been aware that
He was doing it, His spirit became (middle voice of the element,
“BECOME,”) obedient unto death.
To this day, the celestials must still be marveling at such an event.
Until this point, they evidently believed that control by the numbers functioned
best. While various religions have died off over the last 2,000 years, many
celestials have dared to adulterate scripture to keep the fight going!
Yet Christ’s complete lack of pride in self stands tall, regardless
of their opinions. These in the heavens are destined to be reconciled through
Christ’s obedience, and that, I theorize, is as startling an effect as His
self-abasement.
Through Christ’s early life, and well into His ministry, He was being
perfected. He had to learn obedience (Heb. 5:8.) It has been asked,
“Does this mean that Christ, at any time, was disobedient?” The answer
is no. He was without Sin (2 Cor. 5:20.) We may safely infer, then, that He would
have been obedient without knowing it (for it is not a sin to “not know”
something.) Such a concept should be true regardless of when you believe
Christ was created. Christ was always obedient to the Father’s will, and
in this case, His Father willed that Christ was to be obedient unto death – but
this was not tested until the sufferings He endured (Heb. 5:8.)
The process of dying, for Christ, continually educated Him toward what
it meant to obey such a master. If Christ had, at any time, disobeyed
this master, then He would have, in turn, disobeyed God’s will for Him at
that time, and there would be no grounds for His rousing. This yet again
reinforces the fact that Christ had a spirit completely unlike ours.
Whereas we are infected with Rebellion itself, Christ held no such
infirmity. His spirit, unlike ours, gave life – abundant life, the likes
of which only God could convey.
The clear implication here is that, in all ways, Christ was handicapped.
He had a superhuman spirit, yet had come to be in our likeness. He was alone in
the crowd – alive, but buried among the dying. He was mortal only in the
sense that He could die – not in the sense that He was indeed
dying, or He would not have had to “obey” death.
What Sayest Thou, Theologian?
It has, through all of this, been apparent that your average Trinitarian
simply disbelieves the passage. Rationally, no Trinitarian can claim that Jesus
was obeying death and remain a Trinitarian, for they are inherently
claiming that God Himself became subject to the dying state that He had
inflicted on the unrighteous. There are three fundamental issues with this
proclamation.
First, it would be completely out of character with all of God’s
prior action in the Old Testament – demanding that the Israelite raise himself
up to righteousness, and refusing to arbitrarily lower the standards
of right and wrong for anyone. For Him to turn around and suddenly bring
Himself into contact with flesh on a daily basis would undermine all the
distancing He had done before (making them pointless actions, hence further
making Him just like man – making it up as He goes along.) The only proper
solution is that He sends a Sacrifice from the same position, His Son,
to mediate the issue and uplift mankind.
Second, if the Creator had placed Himself under death,
then no one can get Him out. It is an insoluble paradox which falsifies
the text in one or more places. If it is argued that He “can magically
choose to resurrect Himself at any time,” then He is not truly obedient unto
death. If Christ somehow maintains a conscious awareness in death – enough
sentience to paradoxically conduct a resurrection of Himself – then no noteworthy
death has transpired; it would be a show, not a sacrifice of real value.
The clearest problem here is that if Christ did not actually die, then
neither did His enemy, Sin, actually die. This would further make the
planning of Christ’s death a senseless deed. Many Trinitarians actually argue
in favor of this, which is depressing; their god appears to be a grifter, who appears
to defeat Sin, yet never actually does so.
And third, scripture simply does not say that the God and Father
of our Lord Jesus Christ died. You would think that this piece of
evidence is most sufficient in dispelling the Trinitarian rumor! Yet
one’s persistence after being confronted with this fact only highlights the
depth of their dishonor toward God and their disdain for His words. These Gnostics
often argue some elaborate ontological stance in order to say, in short,
something like “God could die and then raise Himself and this is completely
normal and okay!” They then play word games with “die,” so that it does not actually
mean die, but is some “spiritual death” (more on this in Part V.) There is
no verse for this, either; these folk often add “spiritual” at specific
intervals to assert their position.
*
* *
The Socinian’s case is not much better. Keep in mind that, up until this
point, the Reformation theologian has turned this passage into a figurative
mess. Let us briefly track this view through Liam
McAllister’s video on ‘Christ’s Incarnation.’ To Liam, recall, “Form of God” is some “rank or station,”
or “role” which Christ held – an internal title, not an outward appearance
(he says, in more recent videos on the subject, that “role” and “appearance”
are one and the same; such a claim is irrational.) Thus, he claims, Christ enters
the “form of God,” that is, as His “only-begotten Son” (alluding to Clyde
Pilkington’s commentary) when He begins His ministry (thus making the “likeness
of an image of a corruptible man” the outward appearance of God.) Worse still,
at the point of contact – the moment Christ is brought into chains in the
Garden of Gethsemane – He is said to undergo a “role change,” so that He no
longer has the role of “only-begotten” (per Clyde’s commentary, or “Agent
of God,” per Liam’s commentary,) when He is at the cross, and this is
what is meant by “role of a slave!”
Worse still, for Christ to “empty Himself” is, according to Liam,
“a way of describing Christ’s humble disposition… even though He was God’s Son,
He humbled Himself, and became a servant. Every time Jesus voluntarily
submitted His will and desire to His Father’s instead of asserting His own,
He effectively emptied Himself – not of His ‘divine nature,’ or of a body… but
of His pride… of all ambition, self-preservation, and selfish desire.”
Such a view is startingly foolish, for two clear reasons. First,
to change the personality of Christ from one of inherent selflessness
and love to one plagued with the internal qualities of sin is one of the
worst demarcations of our Lord that we’ve ever read (and we’ve read a lot of
Christian literature.) Our Lord did not empty Himself of qualities which He
never internally battled, or of which He never held (2 Cor. 5:21, 1 Pet.
1:19-20.) If there is a way to read Philippians 2 as if Christ was
non-existent at the beginning of the story, this would certainly not be the
re-write necessary to attain such a view.
The second reason is shown in Liam showing he has not studied the
concordant media on this passage (now compiled and available in the “Concordant
Crash Course,” if you ask us for it.) Time and time again, it is asserted by
students of the Concordant Greek Text that “empties” is not limited to a
“body” or of some “nature.” Ambiguous terminology should be thrust aside.
Christ empties Himself of all. There is, again, naught which He held
in the form of God which He takes into the form of a slave, given the force
of the term “empties.” No qualification of the verb is given; to add one
is to add to the word of God.
It is wrong to add to the word of God.
Besides these major problems concerning Liam’s perception of our
Lord, there is another major issue which begs our attention. Regarding the
phrase “likeness of humanity,” Liam claims that this is only “re-affirming
Christ’s humble status when He conformed Himself to the disposition of an
ordinary man.” Such a statement is bafflingly contradictory to Paul’s foundational
claim concerning the ordinary man’s disposition toward God – enmity (Rom.
8:7,) and in emotional terms, “irreverent” and “unjust” (Rom. 1:18.) The
ordinary man’s disposition is not one
of humility; it is the mature man’s disposition of humility that we are
entreated to grow into (Phil. 2:3-5, 3:15-16.)
It is further problematic to presume that the Image of God would, for
some reason, have need to conform to our disposition, that of an “ordinary
man.” If Christ is the Image, the Just Representative of God, then at no point
should His disposition have to “change.” He would accurately reflect God at any
given point during His existence, irrespective of His form. Neither would his
entreaty for us to change our disposition be of any consequence!
By claiming that His disposition “changed” into the “mankind’s
likeness,” there must be the logical concession that it was unlike man’s
at some prior point. Moreover, if we are following Liam’s opinion, then
Christ’s disposition must have been like God’s disposition, making it
all the more confusing that He would have any reason to change that
disposition at the cross when He alone is supposed to beat sin. If He’s
in the ultimate battle against Sin herself, then there is no scriptural
reason for Him to take the disposition of man, who knows nothing
of how to beat sin. He would have to maintain the disposition of the One
who beats Sin!
Yet even this is all a red herring. Paul does not say “likeness of man’s
disposition,” but “likeness of humanity.” He does not say “being
found, in fashion, as a man’s servitude,” but “being found, in fashion,
as a man.” Liam’s view seems to presume that everything following
“empties Himself” in this passage is repetitious, saying practically the same
thing with little difference – Christ conforms Himself, and also conforms
Himself, and too conforms Himself. Such repetitious writing is flawed, and leaves
room for the idea that God’s word is imperfect.
With all of this illogical service (which, by the way, has hardly
dared to confront a single point presented both in this chapter, and the
writings of other prolific writers in the body of Christ, such as A.E.
Knoch or the previous
writings of Thijs Amersfoort,) how, may we ask, does Liam deal with the two
uses of death in Philippians?
The answer is that he doesn’t deal with it at all. As far as we’ve seen,
there has not yet been mention of the two uses of “death” in the passage from
the Socinian camp.
…We’re sorry. We know, we were building that up for a little bit, there.
We wanted the let-down to be as impactful for you as it was for us. If you are
ready to knock Liam for ignoring the first use of death completely, we kindly
ask that you do not do this. You would be missing the forest for the trees. We
would recommend, instead, that you knock the poor reasoning that led to
ignoring this phrase completely, which is not limited to Liam. To
maintain this reasoning, and intentionally dismiss the facts which oppose it,
indicates that one is caught in a trap, and in need of much consolation.
It has been suggested (as is briefly hinted by Peter Meye in his three-and-a-half-hour
treatise,) that the two uses
of death are simply for “emphasis,” and nothing more. Yet this could not be
further from the truth. The Greek, simply put, does not repeat words like this
for emphasis. If a phrase is ever repeated, it is structural (see
‘anathema’ in Gal. 1:8-9, or “rejoice” in Phil. 4:4.) Otherwise, any
repetitious terminology is separated by conjunctions, prepositions, and
particles (see examples like Rom. 1:17, 2 Cor. 2:16, 4:17, and 8:22.) Notably,
in every repetitious use, the thought is expanded upon, noting a progression
of thought, as opposed to merely “repeating the same idea in a different
way,” or “exclaiming” or “clarification.”
In other words, every time Paul employs any repetition, both terms
are inherently valuable to his thought, and the second term always expands
upon the first.
As such, there is no plausible way to assume that the first use
of “death” is the same as the second use of “death.” The first
use of “death” is given no specification, while the second use
of “death” specially regards the cross. The first use of “death,” then, must
relate to the frail figure that Christ was found in, and which led to His
humility, as the prior two clauses clearly indicate, apart from
the cross, and cannot include it.
Thus the Socinian spins for himself another insoluble conundrum: If
Christ is said to “become obedient unto death” at the cross, then Paul
is redundant for repeating the same phrase twice, making a mockery of God’s
perfect writing. Further, the Socinian defeats his own existential argument.
Christ must be Man, indeed, for the sacrifice to eventually reconcile all
creation, but by claiming that Christ became obedient unto death at some
point during His ministry or at the cross, it is conceded that He is somehow
unlike man, for unlike man, He would not have suffered the death
process as we all have suffered hitherto. He would thus have to give credence
to the scriptural claim that we are reading – that Christ existed prior to His
birth.
Moreover, if He was involuntarily subject to death prior
to the cross, then He is a tarnished sacrifice, and both law and the old
creation would still be rampant, since a regular guy was murdered – not the Son
of God (Rom. 8:3-4.) And, if He achieved the ability to “become
obedient” unto death at the cross, then ironically, the Socinian has turned humility
into a standardized, impossible disposition to attain, for we would be
striving to “become obedient unto death,” which not one since Christ has effected,
nor would anyone ever be able to attain it.
A Brief Treatise
By the time you have reached the final clause concerning Christ’s
humiliation – “even the death of the cross” – it should be readily apparent
that neither the Trinitarian nor the Socinian understand the
passage as a whole. Neither group accounts for all of the facts, and sacrifice
logical service for their position. Many interpretive aspects must be called
into question for both – their ability to apprehend the progression of the
aorist, their recognition of the character of Christ, their ability to retain
simple definitions and terms, their ability to spot logistical errors in their
own arguments, and their ability to debar personal philosophy from the passage.
It follows that there is no real reason to endorse any teaching made by
these men on these grounds, as our apostle testifies concerning other believers
(1 Tim. 6:3-5.) For if these men retain such questionable practices on one
passage, then who is to say they are not conducting the same questionable means
on another?
For example… If the pre-supposed methodology of both of these
parties is to be taken at face value, then we may employ it on passages from major
points in Romans as a means to deny plain statements. In Romans 3:22, we read
that apart from law, there is “a righteousness of God through Jesus Christ’s
faith, for all and on all who are believing.” Why can’t we treat faith as a
metaphor, as the Socinian does here? Why can’t we simply change “God” to
“Christ,” as the Trinitarian does? Why not turn the faith of Christ into
our faith in Christ? Take, maybe, a look at 1 Corinthians
15:22-28. Why don’t we pre-suppose that being “in” Christ comes down to
personal choice? According to Socinian logic, we are firmly able to pre-suppose
this, since we are able to dismiss the progression of the text wherever
necessary to admit our personal views. Why can’t we simply change verses 27-28
to some past event, so that the Son is only subject to God because He is in a
humiliated state, to appease a Trinitarian rhetoric?
Even if, say, men in either camp were to take a proper stance
concerning belief in the evangel, or the eons, or some other scriptural truth, how
could the average viewer or reader trust the stance, even if its conclusion is actually
true? If A.E. Knoch publicly argued that “God is the Saviour of all mankind
because He is the Saviour of all mankind,” it would not matter if he is
dogmatically correct. He would turn people away from this great truth
because his argumentation is severely lacking. How could these men make their
claims rationally without shaming the scriptural stance by arguing under confused
means? How can anyone watch or read their content without grave
suspicion that they are not being taught how to think, but being taught what
to think? How does illogical argumentation honor God or His word? Such
a disposition is opposite of the passage we are reading, and does not establish
intelligent reverence, but emotional piety.
Even
Believers in Paul’s evangel should have no trouble identifying the word
translated “even” in Philippians 2:8. It is the conjunction de, appearing
most notably in Romans 3:21, as “yet” in the clause, “yet now.” This is
followed by a packed introduction to the evangel of God, concerning our
justification through Jesus Christ’s faith, in God’s grace. It is employed to
great effect, juxtaposing the hopeless conduct of mankind with the glory of God.
Yet this is not its sole function. It is sometimes translated as “now”
instead of “yet,” to account for its other quality. Sometimes, it is
“adversative,” in which case it will be translated as “yet.” On other
occasions, it is “continuative,” in which case it will be translated as “now”
(see its uses in Matt. 1:2-15 as clear examples of this.)
This use of de is evidently continuative (translated “even” to
account for English idiom.)
The Ultimate Humiliation
“The death of the cross” is the final stage of Christ’s journey, as
presented in Philippians 2:5-8, proven by the progression of the aorist tense
throughout Philippians 2. This is the first reference in the entire
passage to the scene at Golgotha. To force the death of the cross at any point prior
to 2:8 is to jumble the entire passage in a bag, splicing the simple
progression into a complicated one, full of jargon that further require man’s
judgment and opinion to explain. There is no logical reason to import the end
of Phil. 2:8 into the beginning of Phil. 2:6. Never is such reasoning
necessitated by God. When in the “form of God,” His glory as the Image of the
invisible God, and Firstborn of every creature – lovingly called His
“pre-eminent glories” by the concordant crew – are apparent, when the facts
concerning the Greek are taken into consideration.
Yet these excellent qualities – supreme above all others in every aspect
of creation – do not clearly convey the humility of Christ, and thus
cannot display His (thus God’s) heart.
His unjust murder is where His disposition most clearly
shines. Here is a glory, a moral excellence, which could not be revealed by Him
when in the form of God. That glorious theophany of His origin is not a
full-orbed revelation. It needed to be complemented by His course when
found in fashion as a man.
Christ, seeing from the vantage point of supremacy over all, can
accurately survey the playing field. For Him, there is an impassable gap
between God and man. God is above even Christ, and cannot be reached from man’s
lowly place. Man, irreverent and unjust, could not ascend to heaven and grasp
God. God, in His lofty excellence, could not reach our hearts.
Thus we must see Christ in the midst of misery and woe. Christ
recognizes that He alone must bridge this gap. God cannot lay His glory
down, but Christ, Who was gifted such a position, and did not earn
it, was able to do so. Christ empties Himself, not merely of some
position, but of all that He was.
Here it is that God wins our affections through the humiliation of His
Anointed. Christ is not born to great fanfare in the halls of a palace. Such
would be right, but not enough for this One. Instead, He is born in a
cow trough. When He is born, His people are not enthralled to meet Him;
instead, Herod sought to murder Him, going so far as to attempt
infanticide, as Israel’s Egyptian oppressors once did.
As Jesus aged, He grew in wisdom and stature (Luke 2:52.) His
ability to discern the facts became more apparent, and was most clearly
displayed at His baptism:
Now, being baptized, Jesus straightway stepped up from the water, and
lo! opened up to Him were the heavens, and He perceived the spirit of God
descending as if a dove, and coming on Him. And lo! a voice out of the heavens,
saying, “This is My Son, the Beloved, in Whom I delight.”
From here on in, Jesus
was evidently aware of His imminent death (Ma. 16:21, Mk. 10:33-34, Lu. 9:22,
etc.) He knew that He had life in Himself (Jo. 5:26, as opposed to the mocking
view that He had selfish desire in Him that needed to be emptied.) He
knew that He was God’s sacrifice – the Hebrew scriptures could attest such a
fact (Is. 53:9-10.)
He knew the horror of
this death. He would be brutally tortured, mocked, and degraded. His blood
would be drained, yet not fast enough to make the death painless. The
crucifixion He would face was reserved for the most detestable murderers and
thieves (Barrabas is God’s thematic example.) Most importantly, He was willing
to face this death, and see it through to the end. This was a voluntary sojourn
into a death state which would never have come upon Him otherwise. Though, of
course, God is absolutely in control of Christ’s will, Christ was made by God to
voluntarily empty Himself. This concluded with His humbling – causing
Himself to be low when He did nothing to deserve such a state.
It is this grotesque
murder which caused Jesus’ deepest agonies. For the Righteous One to be made
a sin offering is so confounding to mankind that our reasonings in the
body of Christ have still made it difficult to apprehend this fact (2
Cor. 5:21!) Such a career as Jesus’ ministry did not deserve so detestable a
death – Him being without sin altogether – yet His Dad deemed it necessary
to design her ultimate repudiation (Heb. 9:26.)
God, too, shows His
feelings on this matter. During the three hours at the cross, nature itself
revolts in despair with its Arbiter. God throws the ultimate tantrum. A
sorrow unparalleled cried forth from the sky, turning its color black as night
(Matt. 27:45-46.) The heavens wailed in agony as the most Righteous One in the
universe took on the role of Sin, and thus appeared abhorrent to His own
Father.
Christ is the only One
able to effect this role, having a spirit of holiness and aligning with the
lineage of David (Rom. 1:3-4.) We will consider this aspect when we study Col.
1:15-17 more in depth, acknowledging Christ’s role in the plan and purpose of
God, and His various glories conveyed in the passage, most important of all
being the inclusion of all in the Son (as opposed to a false
“substitutionary” sacrifice “offered” to the individual, as Athanasius proposed.)
The Cross
Many in Christ have
already noted that the “cross” is not truly a “cross” at all (like the one you
saw in The Passion of the Christ, or on any fashionable necklace today.)
You can see above that the word “cross” is, literally, a “stake” or “pole.” It
was not an ornament for us to admire, or to hang on our walls with reverence.
It represents the shame and humiliation of Christ, and thus of
the entire human race. Mankind’s reverence for the cross itself, while acknowledging
very little concerning the One Who hung from it, is indeed a sign of the
irreverence of mankind, and proof that God should be discarding the earth
swiftly.
The word “cross” appears
28 times in the New Testament (its verb form, “impale,” appears 42 times.) Paul
most discusses the concept of the “cross” in 1 Corinthians; much of the
information concerning the cross should, of course, already be known to
the student of the scriptures prior to reading this Philippians passage.
This statement in Philippians carries all the weight of the previous info.
Thematically, the Corinthians were the most immature, and thus needed much
information concerning the humbling of the Lord. In contrast, the Thessalonians
(the thematically mature ecclesia presented to us on the other side
of these “perfection” letters) are not deficient concerning this primary
knowledge. To accord with this, the words “cross” and “crucify” are nowhere to
be found.
In the perfection
epistles, the true import of the cross is revealed to us. It is not treated as
“yet another” unjust murder, but as the ultimate unjust murder. On its
own – apart from any recognition of Christ as the Son of God – one could imagine
its tragedy. Literally speaking, it is not physically the most brutal
suffering ever endured. Christ’s bones were not broken, nor did He suffer for
much more than a day, unlike some crucifixions (and don’t even get us started
on the horrific death sentences enforced by “Ahura Mazda” fans.)
The cross must be viewed
in its thematic relation to the rest of the events in the Bible for its depths
to be plumbed, and for the true scope of His sacrifice to be revealed (this is
a task far above our present study.) Christ, in truth, is not like
other men. He did have all of the strength and ability that the
Pharisees denied of Him. If any other man were in Christ’s place, with
the same authority, He would surely have been unable to withstand the degrading
pressure and insult from the crowd; nor would they have been able to carry the
full weight of Sin herself as He did.
The physical murder,
then, is no hodge-podge of cruelty. Each and every cut is representative of a
much greater spiritual sorrow. His physical body was razed, as the seed
of David – yet only His spirit could enduree the oppression of God. At
the cross, the connection between the Son and the Father were severed for the
first time in history. Christ became obedient – not merely to death, but
to the death of the cross. This death was so grievous that He was
alienated from His Father for the first time in Their relationship.
“Eloi! Eloi! Lema Sebachthani!” – that is, “My God, My God, why have
You forsaken Me?”
It is all well and good
to acknowledge the desertion of our Lord by all men. The Jewish nation did not
care, envying Him instead of acknowledging His authority over
them. They created false charges to murder Him. The strongest power on earth at
the time – the Roman empire – hosted this murder. The strongest political and
religious principalities on the earth worked together with the strongest
celestial principality for His death.
Yet we often ignore the most
pressing loss Christ faced, and this is tragic, for it is the crux of our
story. There is much emotional weight in the scene, simply as it is – but its
weight transcends rational thought when we consider Jesus’ cry. He was hurt by
men – but overwhelmed by the absence of God. To become a sin offering,
He was placed on the other side of the spiritual “curtain,” so to speak.
He was lumped in with the rest of creation. This One, Who always had God,
regardless of His form, truly became like everyone else. There was no one, it
seemed, to feel the greatest hurt with Him. For it was, ultimately, God
– His Father – Who had willed for Him to go to that cross (Is. 53:9-10.)
Forget mankind, or the celestials – the Power of the universe had
brought Him to this ruinous place.
He was alone.
The question, naturally,
is, why did the God of love do something like this? How could God perceive
such a scene as the right course of action?
As we have discussed
throughout our Romans study, it is this murder that has, through its
horror, blessed all. Without the cross, we cannot be justified (Rom.
3:21-4:25.) Without the cross, God cannot conciliate (John 12:32,
Rom. 5:1-8:30, 2 Cor. 5:18-21, Col. 1:20-21.) This unblemished and
perfect sacrifice – not one that “had” sin and “emptied” Himself of it,
but of One Who was without sin – is now the permanent basis of all of
God’s blessing. The Father and the Son were briefly severed so that a true,
familial relationship between you (yes, you, dear reader) and God
is established. It is the inevitable outcome of sin’s complete loss, and
moreover God’s vast love.
The cross serves a vivid
contrast to His place at the Head of the universe. For this One to have
been considered God’s equal in His inherent form, to be brought to such
a low position, is even still unfathomable, upon reading it. Christ
was as close to God as One has ever been, and all will be. None have yet ever
approached the Deity except through Him. He is the Chief
Messenger (1 Thess. 4:16.) He is the Idol of God, the Emblem of God’s
assumption (Heb. 1:3-4.) So far as creation was concerned, prior to His death, Jesus
was God (Lu. 1:68, Jo. 1:1, 18, etc.) He portrayed this outward
appearance of God for communion with the universe.
Yet, during Jesus’
crucifixion, we face the opposite extreme. In the form of a slave, having
the outward appearance of death’s jurisdiction, He was conformed to man’s
appearance in dirt. His connection from His Dad had been severed. Instead, He
had to endure the mockery of those who claimed to have a closer connection to
God than He did. In every conceivable way, He could not have been further from
His prior place.
Having been emptied, it
was through faith alone that He endured. He did what those who mocked
Him never could – He believed that the God and Father, Who in every
rational way could not be conceived as “righteous” during that scene, was
righteous, and did have a purpose for what appeared to be the most
senseless murder ever committed. It is this point at the cross where the faith
of Christ shines the brightest (Rom. 3:22, 24-25) – something which could
never have been grasped apart from the severity of the ordeal.
What Sayest Thou, Gob Bluth?
Christ Himself cried out
to His God. “My God,” Christ cries. This is no error; Christ Himself explicitly
proclaims that He has a God. This has been waved off by Trinitarians,
who generally claim that “Jesus, while being God, had divested Himself of
Godhood while on earth in order to assume the role of a ‘subject.’” This is
usually claimed to correlate Christ ‘pre-existent’ and ‘post-ascension’ as “the
God.” This interpretation understands His cries to God as expressions of His
assumed human nature and voluntary subordination to the Father.
In other words, the
Trinitarian supposes that Christ “emptied” Himself of divine nature, taking
on a special human nature for a brief 33-year stint, and then regained
this divine nature to ascend. Thus, Trinitarians distinguish between
Christ’s “eternal identity” as God the Son and His earthly role as the “incarnate
Son,” who depended fully on the Father without ceasing to be divine.
Now, we are only framing
the position as they themselves provide it. Prominent theologians as
Thomasius, Crosby, and Gore across the 19th century pose these same arguments.
We add this because you may get the sense that the Trinitarian is trying to
have their cake and eat it, too. “Christ divests Himself of divine attributes,
but retains some divine nature, but gains a complete human nature as well.”
The theory simply fails,
due to Phil. 2:6, where the simple definition of the word “form” (outward appearance,
not intrinsic attributes,) debunks the theory. It is further compounded
by Paul’s claim in Col. 1:15, which we will consider later. With the
Trinitarian logic, Christ would have to regain His “God-hood” or
“God-ship” when He ascends again, thus ceasing the idea that He has a
“God.” Thus the burden of proof is on the Trinitarian to prove that
Christ ceased to have a God after His ascension. This is a
problem, for the ascended Christ is expressly said to have a God. The
Father is called the God of our Lord Jesus Christ (Eph. 1:3, 17), making
Christ’s subjection to His God no temporary arrangement. His
relationship to His Placer, then, is not confined to His earthly sojourn.
God the Father is the
Supreme. He has no god. He does not subject Himself to Christ. At no time is
the Son treated as superior to the Father. Again, equality necessarily indicates
two – not one. If God were dependent on the Son (or creation,)
then He would not be absolute. He cannot suffer humiliation from the
departure of others. He may be lied about by those others, and He
may hurt for their absence, but He Himself is not “made low” by the loss
of others. He does not die. Death requires one have a body (Gen. 3:18.) And,
even if He had died, the Spirit which powered creation would no longer
function. Nor could He “commit His spirit” to some other, higher power. He
would be a completely unsuitable sacrifice.
Mankind is the opposite
of all of this. Mankind does have a God, and we are subordinate.
Only a Mediator could bridge this gap (1 Tim. 2:5.) He must be found in fashion
as a man. He must have a divine spirit (Rom. 1:4.) The fusion of both of
these aspects in One is what makes Christ an admissible sacrifice for
the sake of all. Christ, unlike God, is nowhere explained as an “eternal” Being
(more on this in Part V, but in short, there’s simply no verse which claims
this.) He is always shown to be dependent on the Father. Hence He can (and
does) suffer the greatest experience of evil – and thus the greatest
humiliation (Ecc. 1:13, 3:10.) He loses all – even the One Who gave Him
such an experience, and Who had always shown Himself present.
* * *
I must briefly pause,
here, and note that this is certainly not the end of the “cross”
discussion. Fans of the Bible may recall that the cross is again mentioned in Colossians
1:20. The thought of the cross, in this Philippians passage, carries the weight
of the prior teaching, but the direct stress is not on our blessing.
It is indeed on Christ and His disposition during the ultimate
suffering. This phrase, “the death of the cross,” is the darkest portion of the
passage, and necessarily so. The complementary sentences in 2:9-11, concerning
the glories post Resurrection hinge upon the consequences of the cross –
first, in relation to Jesus (2:9,) second, its effects upon you (2:10-11a,) and
finally, the purpose of this humbling (2:11b.)
In a brief addendum,
then, we will reflect upon Phil. 2:9-11. We have not exhausted this subject
(nor could we rationally hope to,) but it is better to save the practical effects
of the cross for all for Part III, since it covers the destiny of
all created creatures. This includes maturing into the disposition Paul
has presented for us in Phil. 2:5-8.
And what a presentation!
We have now witnessed our Lord’s descent from the form of God to the form of a
slave. Objections from both Trinitarian and Socinian camps have greatly deepened
our understanding of these doctrines. It is a great blessing to see the truth
of God on the background of such falsehoods.
While we still have a
ways to go, we believe Part II has been instrumental in helping us define where
we stand on this whole matter. We know that most will portray us as
“Unitarian,” or “Arian,” or impose some other theological name upon us. If we must
be labeled, we will respond to “Concordant.” At the end of the day, we have
been graced to follow this singular method. It is the road (far) less
traveled. Whether this leads us to accept a statement from a religious sect, we
are unfazed. We will never perceive strawmen as intellectual, and are not
obligated to reply to them; where one wishes to respond using the same consistent
method, we are more than happy to sit and learn.
In the meantime, we are
delighted to have learned. We will see you in Part III!
- GerudoKing, Seth Fahlenkamp, Jordan White

Comments
Post a Comment